After a day of sightseeing in the Haifa area -- the beautiful Baha'i shrine and gardens, old Akko, and the grottoes of Rosh HaNikra, we set off tomorrow for the Kinneret for two days in Tiberias. Of course, things in Israel can always get a little crazy. Turns out that there was some rocket fire from the Gaza onto Sderot, and a resulting air strike by the Israelis on Gaza. So, what would have been a trip to the Lebanese border (the great view at Manara) tomorrow will be curtailed to a short visit to the Naot factory which is sort of near the Lebanese border. Fun, fun, fun, though more for pure caution's sake -- there's no imminent threat from Hezbollah as the UN and Israel has them mostly under control.
Otherwise, trucking along in our monstrous van across the Israeli countryside. Tiberias, then a quick detour to Yafo, an afternoon in Beit Shemesh (a suburb of Jerusalem) and then five days in Jerusalem. More tomorrow on Tzfat, the center of Kaballah.
Saturday, December 27, 2008
Friday, December 26, 2008
Welcome Party
Sitting in Ben-Gurion Airport, waiting for another member of our group to arrive. The area where people leave customs is quite remarkable. Because almost all trips to Israel have aspects of both pilgrimage and homecoming, there is much fanfare about arrivals. Cheering, balloons, flowers, huge crowds - you see it all. Sure, it happens at every airport, but nothing like to this extent.
Commandment #2, Harder Than You Thought
Greetings from the bustling pre-Shabbat Shuk HaCarmel in Tel Aviv. So the first thing we did in Israel was to go to the Kotel (Western Wall) in Jerusalem. It's considered the center of Judaism because it's the last remnant of the Temple complex destroyed by the Romans in 70 CE. It's a place that raises a lot of emotions, but is that right? The second commandment says that we can't have idols, so why do we let a wall replace God in some ways? Are we worshipping it?
Thursday, December 25, 2008
I am not a crook
Today is December 25th. A celebration all over the world. Some spend time with family and open presents while others go to the movies and eat Chinese food. I, like most Jewish people, are in the latter half. This year, the selection of Christmas day movie candidates was rather thin. Usually, this is the time of year that all the Oscar worthy movies come out. This year I was underwhelmed with the possible selections. Not that my selections in good years have ever been stellar. In fact, over the past few years, my track record of Christmas day selections downright stinks. Last year, National Treasure 2: Electric Boogaloo came out. That movie most likely will not make the list of AFI's top 100 movies the next time it is distributed. Over the past few years, Christmas Day selections have included The Producers (a movie based on a play based on a movie?), Babel (zzzzzzz.....), and Spanglish (no esta bien).
Based on my track record, we were extra picky this year in our Christmas movie selection even soliciting suggestions from people in the know. We settled on Frost/Nixon, a Ron Howard movie starring a whole bunch of people that you know from somewhere but can't recall exactly where you know them from. It also stars Kevin Bacon, just in case you run out of ways to link Kevin Bacon to other actors. I know I haven't seen very many movies this year but Frost/Nixon wins my vote for movie of the year. The acting was superb. Frank Langella should be a very strong candidate for Best Actor for his portrayal of Tricky Dick. The storyline was moving, as you don't know whether to sympathize or hate Nixon as he goes through his cathartic admission of guilt in the Watergate scandal. The docu-drama style of filiming helps tie the movie together. Two thumbs up from me.
Other random thoughts:
Based on my track record, we were extra picky this year in our Christmas movie selection even soliciting suggestions from people in the know. We settled on Frost/Nixon, a Ron Howard movie starring a whole bunch of people that you know from somewhere but can't recall exactly where you know them from. It also stars Kevin Bacon, just in case you run out of ways to link Kevin Bacon to other actors. I know I haven't seen very many movies this year but Frost/Nixon wins my vote for movie of the year. The acting was superb. Frank Langella should be a very strong candidate for Best Actor for his portrayal of Tricky Dick. The storyline was moving, as you don't know whether to sympathize or hate Nixon as he goes through his cathartic admission of guilt in the Watergate scandal. The docu-drama style of filiming helps tie the movie together. Two thumbs up from me.
Other random thoughts:
- I didn't think the Lakers-Celtics game would live up to the endless hype that ESPN had been giving the game. However, the game was great from start to finish (even if evil defeated good). I can't wait until they meet again in June. On a side note, I don't know how I never noticed this before but Pau Gasol has to be one of the ugliest basketball players alive. Popeye Jones and Sam Cassell are one-two in some order but Gasol is a close third.
- Is showing A Christmas Story twelve times on TBS today really going to get better ratings than, say, a Saved By the Bell marathon? If you are watching A Christmas Story at 4:30 in the morning, you'd better have a newborn child with you.
Wednesday, December 24, 2008
Don't Narc On Me
While Josh is floating somewhere over the Atlantic Ocean, I will try to keep his streak of blogging intact.
Today, I completed my first Craigslist transaction. The entire experience totally made me feel like a drug dealer. Let me set up the story. Last week on the radio, I had won a Guitar Hero game for the Nintendo Wii. My only problem is that I don't have a Wii. I tried playing the "my brother gave me a gift for the wrong system" game at Best Buy, Toys R Us and GameStop but could not find anyone willing to swap a Wii game for a PS2 game even though the Wii game sells for $15 more. I decided Craigslist was the way to go.
I posted the game Monday night with the guarantee that I would drive it to their place in time for Christmas, Chanukah, Kwanzaa or Festivus. A few hours later, I received a response. I found my buyer. Luckily, he lived only a few blocks from me so delivery would not be a problem. When I arrived at the person's house, the front door was open even though the temperature was rather chilly. I immediately found this kinda sketchy. The "merchandise" was in the trunk of my car. The buyer, a college kid, walks out his front door, checking me out as he approaches. He quickly stuffs a few unmarked bills in my hand, grabs the game and quickly scurries inside. The entire transaction took less than 15 seconds. It just felt really weird. I don't know why but now I know exactly what drug dealers go through. Now if I can only get sell the VRE pass that I was given...
As for the links of the day, here a couple of fun theme songs.
1) Have you ever wondered exactly what kind of relationship Larry and Balki had going on with each other? There is way too much touching in this intro.
2) Am I the only person who is still waiting for the final episode of Alf?
Today, I completed my first Craigslist transaction. The entire experience totally made me feel like a drug dealer. Let me set up the story. Last week on the radio, I had won a Guitar Hero game for the Nintendo Wii. My only problem is that I don't have a Wii. I tried playing the "my brother gave me a gift for the wrong system" game at Best Buy, Toys R Us and GameStop but could not find anyone willing to swap a Wii game for a PS2 game even though the Wii game sells for $15 more. I decided Craigslist was the way to go.
I posted the game Monday night with the guarantee that I would drive it to their place in time for Christmas, Chanukah, Kwanzaa or Festivus. A few hours later, I received a response. I found my buyer. Luckily, he lived only a few blocks from me so delivery would not be a problem. When I arrived at the person's house, the front door was open even though the temperature was rather chilly. I immediately found this kinda sketchy. The "merchandise" was in the trunk of my car. The buyer, a college kid, walks out his front door, checking me out as he approaches. He quickly stuffs a few unmarked bills in my hand, grabs the game and quickly scurries inside. The entire transaction took less than 15 seconds. It just felt really weird. I don't know why but now I know exactly what drug dealers go through. Now if I can only get sell the VRE pass that I was given...
As for the links of the day, here a couple of fun theme songs.
1) Have you ever wondered exactly what kind of relationship Larry and Balki had going on with each other? There is way too much touching in this intro.
2) Am I the only person who is still waiting for the final episode of Alf?
Packing
Packing for Israel and not wanting to blog about anything because of the f***ing Yankees (and I don't feel like touching on that), so I'll just leave you with a concert video. The next time I post will be from Tel Aviv or Jerusalem (depending on what strikes me when). In the meantime, here is the greatest Christmas song ever. Honestly. Sorry, Marissa.
Monday, December 22, 2008
Lies, Damn Lies, And Hebrew School
We all know that we baby our kids nowadays. We give trophies to losers, steer kids away from true competition, protect them from things that end up giving them worse allergies or keep them from understanding the value of hard work. Is all that true or not? Who knows, I'm sure that people said that my generation had it too easy when we were kids. It's all relative, probably blown out of proportion. However, I can think of one pretty long-term damaging way in that we inexplicably protect our kids.
Hebrew School.
No, I'm not one of those people who hated their hebrew school experience so much that they think the overall concept is useless garbage. I also don't mean that hebrew school, in principle, damages kids. It's all those lies that we tell them in their education that hurts them, through a lessened understanding of their religion and their cultural history, and there's no better example than Chanukah, the holiday currently happening.
Here's the story of Chanukah, as told (to me and many others) in hebrew school: Antiochus, the Greek king of Syria, was ruling over Israel. He banned practice of the Jewish religion in order to make the Jews supplicant to Greece. Matthias and his sons rose up against Antiochus and won a long war. They took the Temple back in Jerusalem, but it had been desecrated. They wanted to re-sanctify it by cleaning it and re-lighting the everlasting light, but they only had enough oil for one day. After sending a runner for more oil, the original oil miraculously lasted for eight nights and the Temple was saved.
We Jews have heard that countless times and I'm sure many Gentiles have, as well. It's the only holiday with some serious historical credibility (Flavius). The problem is that this story sounds basically impossible. How could some townspeople from Modi'in legitimately defeat Alexander the Great's army, even a small part of it? Are we expected to just swallow a miracle with no questioning? The only thing that can explain it is God, right? Well, when you're talking about a story that old (late second century, BCE), there are a lot of ways for people to tweak it.
Here's what modern scholars agree was the real story: Alexander was conquering everywhere, including Israel and into Egypt. His Hellenic culture was so strong and so attractive that Jews began to follow it. As is still the case in Judaism, from Israel to Brooklyn, the ultra-observant Jews saw this assimilation as a threat to the religion's future. The leader of one of these ultra-observant groups, Matthias (Matisyahu in Hebrew), led his sons in a civil war against the Hellenized Jews. This group, the Maccabis, won the war and took back the capital in Jerusalem. The Temple had been desecrated, so they needed a ceremony to re-sanctify it. When Solomon built the original Temple, he opened it during Sukkot, leading to an eight day festival. The new rulers, the Hasmoneans, decided to honor that tradition with an eight day festival. They had plenty enough oil. Later, as they formed the post-Temple religion, the Rabbis decided that they didn't like a story that glorified only men, so they added the whole miracle thing to add God's presence.
So what gives? Why did I not learn that story until recently? We teach the kids the traditional Rabbinical stories, leaving out any potential disagreements with history. There doesn't seem to be a good reason for this. If nothing else, you can teach young kids the fun, simple stories and then teach older kids the more complex side in order to promote discussion and help them grow in the understanding of Judaism.
I'm not as familiar with non-Jewish religious schools, but I have to think the same sort of thing goes on. And that's one of my biggest problems with organized religion. If you're as confident in your views/"truths" as you seems to be, why not present potential arguments? Showing the challenges should only strengthen that faith as answers are found. Instead you end up with people blindly following whatever they're told, true or not, and nobody likes the thought of that.
Hebrew School.
No, I'm not one of those people who hated their hebrew school experience so much that they think the overall concept is useless garbage. I also don't mean that hebrew school, in principle, damages kids. It's all those lies that we tell them in their education that hurts them, through a lessened understanding of their religion and their cultural history, and there's no better example than Chanukah, the holiday currently happening.
Here's the story of Chanukah, as told (to me and many others) in hebrew school: Antiochus, the Greek king of Syria, was ruling over Israel. He banned practice of the Jewish religion in order to make the Jews supplicant to Greece. Matthias and his sons rose up against Antiochus and won a long war. They took the Temple back in Jerusalem, but it had been desecrated. They wanted to re-sanctify it by cleaning it and re-lighting the everlasting light, but they only had enough oil for one day. After sending a runner for more oil, the original oil miraculously lasted for eight nights and the Temple was saved.
We Jews have heard that countless times and I'm sure many Gentiles have, as well. It's the only holiday with some serious historical credibility (Flavius). The problem is that this story sounds basically impossible. How could some townspeople from Modi'in legitimately defeat Alexander the Great's army, even a small part of it? Are we expected to just swallow a miracle with no questioning? The only thing that can explain it is God, right? Well, when you're talking about a story that old (late second century, BCE), there are a lot of ways for people to tweak it.
Here's what modern scholars agree was the real story: Alexander was conquering everywhere, including Israel and into Egypt. His Hellenic culture was so strong and so attractive that Jews began to follow it. As is still the case in Judaism, from Israel to Brooklyn, the ultra-observant Jews saw this assimilation as a threat to the religion's future. The leader of one of these ultra-observant groups, Matthias (Matisyahu in Hebrew), led his sons in a civil war against the Hellenized Jews. This group, the Maccabis, won the war and took back the capital in Jerusalem. The Temple had been desecrated, so they needed a ceremony to re-sanctify it. When Solomon built the original Temple, he opened it during Sukkot, leading to an eight day festival. The new rulers, the Hasmoneans, decided to honor that tradition with an eight day festival. They had plenty enough oil. Later, as they formed the post-Temple religion, the Rabbis decided that they didn't like a story that glorified only men, so they added the whole miracle thing to add God's presence.
So what gives? Why did I not learn that story until recently? We teach the kids the traditional Rabbinical stories, leaving out any potential disagreements with history. There doesn't seem to be a good reason for this. If nothing else, you can teach young kids the fun, simple stories and then teach older kids the more complex side in order to promote discussion and help them grow in the understanding of Judaism.
I'm not as familiar with non-Jewish religious schools, but I have to think the same sort of thing goes on. And that's one of my biggest problems with organized religion. If you're as confident in your views/"truths" as you seems to be, why not present potential arguments? Showing the challenges should only strengthen that faith as answers are found. Instead you end up with people blindly following whatever they're told, true or not, and nobody likes the thought of that.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)